Option ARMs: The Next Real Estate Crisis

Business Week calls Option ARMs The Next Real Estate Crisis. The article opens with this analogy:

The American homeowner must feel like one of those characters in an old cartoon who has just been hit by a falling piano. After dusting himself off and touching the large bump on his head, he probably doesn't expect another piano to be dangling overhead. But he'd be wrong.

The piano is the impending crisis caused by Option ARMs resetting to higher payments. These previous posts of mine took a look at Option ARMs: original post and an update.

The Business Week article gives us an update on some key statistics:

According to Credit Suisse (CS), monthly option recasts are expected to accelerate starting in April, 2009, from $5 billion to a peak of about $10 billion in January, 2010. Some of these loans have already started to recast. About 13% of option ARMs that were issued in 2006 were delinquent by 60 days by the time they were 18 months old, Credit Suisse said.

About a million borrowers have option ARMs, but only a fraction have already fallen due. [NOTE: should read "only a fraction have already recast."]

Among the states expected to be worst-hit is already battered California. Today, outstanding option ARM loans in the U.S. total about $500 billion, about 60% of which were sold to California homeowners, according to Credit Suisse.

Previously I had posted Credit Suisse's chart on resetting ARMs. This chart did not account for the payments recasting when the balance had grown larger than the recast amount of 110%, 115% or 125%.

The Business Week article now has Credit Suisse's updated chart accounting for recasts. According to the chart, the amount of Option ARMs recasting will rise from the current pace of about $2 billion a month to about $4 billion a month by the end of this year to about $10 billion a month by the end of next year. This is roughly $120 billion resetting in 2008 and 2009 with another $80 billion in 2010.

I posted this chart from IndyMac in my original Option ARM post. To update the status of the top 6: Washington Mutual stripped their CEO of the chairman title, Countrywide is being bailed out by Bank of America, American Home Mortgage went bankrupt, Wachovia fired their CEO, IndyMac is struggling to survive, and Capital One shut down their mortgage division. The others on the list are feeling the pain as well.

The mortgages that are resetting now have huge payment shocks. In an example I used in this post, a borrower with a first payment due in January 2005 had a beginning payment of $574.06 a month. The loan in that example reset in February 2008 to a payment of $1,468.43. That is a huge difference. Especially if the borrower could only afford the teaser payments. Many borrowers that took out these type of loans expected real estate prices to rise faster than their negative amortization. Instead, their loans are hitting 110% or 115% of their original balance causing resets and real estate prices instead of going up faster, have declined.

Wall Street is starting to address the potential problems involving Option ARMs. The recent surge in delinquencies is helping draw attention to this sector of loans.

Sphere: Related Content